FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Thesis, documentation, books

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 15 |

«April 2012 “The test of a democracy is how you treat people incarcerated, people in jail, and especially so with minors.” Mark Regev Spokesman ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Bound, Blindfolded and Convicted:

Children held in military detention

April 2012

“The test of a democracy is how

you treat people incarcerated,

people in jail, and especially

so with minors.”

Mark Regev

Spokesman for the Israeli Prime Minister,

Benyamin Netanyahu

The Guardian, 22 January 2012


A. Executive summary

B. Introduction



C. Overview of the Israeli military detention system

Structural framework

Legal framework

Establishment of a military juvenile court

Recent amendments to the military law – Military Order 1676

Raising the age of majority

Notifying parents of arrest

Notifying a lawyer of arrest

Offences under military law and sentencing

D. Children in the Israeli military detention system


Time of arrest

Notification of reasons for arrest and location of detention

Methods and means of restraint

End notes

| Bound, Blindfolded and Convicted S ince 1967, Palestinians from the West Bank have been living under Israeli military law and prosecuted in military courts. The United Nations (UN) estimates that during the last 44 years, around 726,000 Palestinian men, women and children have been prosecuted and detained under these emergency laws. In the past 11 years alone, around 7,500 children, some as young as 12 years, are estimated to have been detained, interrogated, and imprisoned within this system. This averages out at between 500-700 children per year, or nearly two children, each and every day.

This Report is the culmination of four years’ work during which time sworn testimonies were collected from 311 children held in Israeli military detention. The Report focuses on the period of time between the child’s arrest and being brought before a military court for the first time. The testimonies reveal that the majority of children are detained in the middle of the night in what are typically described as terrifying raids conducted by the army. Most children have their hands painfully tied behind their backs and are blindfolded, before being taken away to an unknown location for interrogation. The arrest and transfer process is often accompanied by verbal abuse and humiliation, threats as well as physical violence. Hours later the children find themselves in an interrogation room, alone, sleep deprived, bruised and scared. Unlike Israeli children living in settlements in the West Bank, Palestinian children are not accompanied by a parent and are generally interrogated without the benefit of legal advice, or being informed of their right to silence.

The testimonies reveal that most children undergo a coercive interrogation, mixing verbal abuse, threats and physical violence, generally resulting in a confession. The most common offence children confess to is throwing stones. The Report also finds that in 29 percent of cases, the children are either shown, or made to sign, documentation written in Hebrew, a language they do not understand.

Within eight days of their arrest, the children are brought in chains to a military court where, in most cases, they will see a lawyer and their parents for the first time. Although many children maintain their innocence, in the end at least 90 percent will plead guilty, as this is the quickest way out of a system that denies children bail in 87 percent of cases.

Within days of their arrest, nearly two-thirds of the children are transferred to prisons inside Israel in violation of Article 76 of the Fourth Geneva Convention, which prohibits such transfers. The practical consequences of this is that many children receive either limited, or no family visits, due to freedom of movement restrictions and the time it takes to issue a permit to visit the prisons.

In addition to an analysis of the 311 testimonies collected from children detained in the military detention system, the Report includes 25 detailed case studies of children, as well as interviews with a lawyer, a rehabilitation expert, a former Israeli soldier and an expert medical report into the mental health implications for the children. The Report also contains a complete list of all 311 testimonies with details of the ill-treatment and issues of concern encountered by each child, as well as a comprehensive list of relevant UN, governmental and NGO reports, and media articles.

The Report finds that when the totality of the evidence is considered, a pattern of systematic ill-treatment emerges, much of which amounts to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, as defined in the UN Convention against Torture, and in some cases, torture – both of which are absolutely prohibited. The Report also finds that there is a general absence of effective complaint mechanisms, which is best summed up in the | Bound, Blindfolded and Convicted

following extract taken from a report published by a well respected Israeli organisation:

“The chances of a criminal offence carried out by an IDF soldier against a Palestinian successfully navigating the obstacle course of the complaint procedure [...] are almost nil.” Although no child should be prosecuted in a military court which lacks comprehensive fair trial and juvenile justice standards, the Report concludes by making 10 recommendations intended to provide a series of simple and practical protective measures. These recommendations include a call for an end to night time arrests, children to have access to a lawyer prior to questioning, all interrogations to be audio-visually recorded, and every child to be accompanied by a parent.

The following table presents a summary of the findings following analysis of the 311 testimonies and highlights 12 issues of concern that were selected because of the frequency with which they were raised by the children.

S ince the establishment of Defence for Children International-Palestine Section (DCIPalestine) in 1991, the organisation has represented over 3,000 Palestinian children in Israeli military courts, and visited a similar number of children held in prisons. Over the past 20 years, the organisation has received reports on a weekly basis from these children alleging that they have been mistreated whilst in the custody of Israeli military and civilian authorities. If proven, many of these reports would violate the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, and constitute cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, for the purposes of the UN Convention against Torture.1 In some cases, the treatment would amount to torture.

Due to the serious nature of these allegations, and the absolute prohibition against torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment (torture and ill-treatment), DCI-Palestine, with the support of the European Union, has undertaken an extensive documentation project commencing on 1 January 2008.2 The Report presents the findings of this work so far, between 1 January 2008 and 31 January 2012 (reporting period). During the reporting period, in addition to providing free legal assistance and conducting prison visits, lawyers and fieldworkers for DCI-Palestine have collected sworn testimonies from children detained within the system, with a view to better assessing and verifying the reports of torture and ill-treatment, as well as highlighting other issues of concern within the system.

The Report presents the findings of the analysis of 311 testimonies collected during the reporting period. In addition to these testimonies, DCI-Palestine has collected a further 68 testimonies from children detained in occupied East Jerusalem. The findings of these testimonies are included in a separate report as Israel applies its civilian law in East Jerusalem, as opposed to military law which is applied to Palestinian children living in the West Bank.3

Child arrest, Beit Ummar: © Maan News | Bound, Blindfolded and Convicted

Methodology The Report is based on the testimonies of 311 children from the West Bank, who were detained by the Israeli army or police during the reporting period. A comprehensive list of all 311 testimonies collected during the reporting period, including the child’s age, date of arrest and the type of treatment experienced, is contained at the end of the Report in Annex 1.

The testimonies were collected by DCI-Palestine lawyers and fieldworkers in accordance with established UN standards.4 The lawyers and fieldworkers were trained to ask a series of non-leading questions specifically focussing on the period of time between the child’s arrest and being brought before a military court for the first time. The overwhelming majority of the testimonies were collected from children while they were in detention, and the events were still fresh in their memories. The age ranges of the children who

provided testimonies are presented in Table 2:

In the overwhelming majority of cases, the testimonies were provided by boys (97 percent), with nine testimonies being provided by girls (3 percent) – a split that slightly over represents the number of girls detained in the system at most given times (Annex 3).

In their testimonies, the children recount their experiences in chronological order, from the moment of their arrest, through their transfer to a detention facility and their subsequent interrogation and appearance before a military court. The time frame covered in the testimonies generally ranges from several days, up to several weeks, but occasionally longer.

The Report follows these children on their journey through the system and seeks to identify any commonly recurring patterns of ill-treatment, such as the excessive use of force and painful methods of restraint. The Report also seeks to identify other aspects of the system which either alone or cumulatively, may have an adverse physical or mental impact on children, such as conducting arrests in the middle of the night using heavily armed soldiers. This analysis forms the primary evidentiary basis for the Report. Where relevant, the Report also refers to reports by UN agencies and experts, governments and NGOs, media outlets and data obtained from the Israel Prison Service (IPS) (Annexes 4, 5 and 6).

| 13 Israeli military juvenile detention system - 2012 S ince the occupation of Palestinian territory in 1967, Palestinians have been charged with offences under Israeli military law and tried in military courts. It is estimated that 726,000 Palestinian men, women and children have been detained under these orders during the past 44 years.6 Israel, as an occupying power, claims the right under international humanitarian law to establish military courts in the territory it has occupied since 1967.7 However, applicable international human rights and humanitarian law nevertheless restricts the jurisdiction of such courts and guarantees certain fundamental fair trial rights.8 Furthermore, it is doubtful whether the use of military courts to try civilians can ever satisfy the requirements under international human rights law to a trial before an independent and impartial tribunal, particularly in the circumstances of a prolonged military occupation that is now of questionable legality.9 Generally speaking, the Israeli military courts prosecute Palestinians who live in the West Bank and hold West Bank identity cards. Palestinians with Jerusalem identity cards are generally prosecuted in the Israeli civilian criminal justice system, even though East Jerusalem is considered to be part of the Occupied Palestinian Territory under international law.10 Since Israel’s “disengagement” from the Gaza Strip in September 2005, Palestinians from Gaza detained by Israeli authorities are generally prosecuted in Israel under civilian security legislation, and not under military law. Palestinians living inside Israel, who hold Israeli citizenship or rights of residency, are also prosecuted in the civilian criminal justice system, as are Israeli children, including those living in settlements in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem.11 Palestinians from the West Bank, who are accused of offences against other Palestinians, are generally prosecuted in Palestinian courts.

Structural framework The Israeli military detention system consists of a network of military bases, interrogation and detention centres and police stations in the West Bank, East Jerusalem and in Israel.

Palestinians, predominantly from the West Bank, are initially taken to one of these facilities for questioning and temporary detention.12 Some of these facilities are inside settlements in the West Bank. Palestinians, including children, remain at these facilities while awaiting sentencing by the military courts, or are transferred to prisons, most of which are located inside Israel, where they wait to be sentenced, or to serve out their prison terms.13 It should be noted that the transfer of Palestinian detainees, including children, to temporary detention facilities and prisons inside Israel, violates Article 76 of the Fourth Geneva Convention, which prohibits such transfers.14 There are currently two military courts used to prosecute Palestinians, including children, both of which are in the West Bank.15 Access to both military courts is strictly controlled.

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |   ...   | 15 |

Similar works:

«Leadership & the Project Manager ©2009 Art Petty 1 Management Excellence at http://artpetty.com Table of Contents Acknowledgements Introduction Why You Must Develop Leadership Skills to Succeed as a Project Manager.5 Your First Lesson, Leading is Hard Work. Getting it Right is Even Harder.6 When Project Managers Stumble as Leaders The Four Universal Qualities of Top Performers & Effective Leaders.9 Your Leadership Foundation: Credibility Are You a Strategy-Fueled Project Manager? Donʼt Feed...»

«Date 27 March 2015 RE: Discussion Paper on Share Classes of UCITS (ESMA/2014/1577) (the Paper) Your input – Consultations We refer to the Paper and the invitation to receive feedback responses. The IFIA and the Irish UCITS industry The Irish Funds Industry Association (IFIA) is the representative body for the international investment fund community in Ireland. Founded in 1991, the IFIA represents custodian banks, administrators, investment managers, transfer agents, fund promoters and...»

«CHAPTER 10 Exploring the Many Meanings of Action Learning and ARL Victoria J. Marsick As have many, I accidentally found out that there is a name for the experience-based learning activities I have always liked to design and facilitate — Action Learning. I encountered educational change programs in India, Nepal, the Philippines, and Bangladesh that shared these characteristics, but I never knew that it had a name. All I knew was that such programs centered around a belief that learning is...»

«ProSecure Web/Email Security Threat Management (STM) Appliance Reference Manual T AF R D NETGEAR, Inc. 350 East Plumeria Drive San Jose, CA 95134 202-10519-01 1.0 September 2009 © 2009 by NETGEAR, Inc. All rights reserved. Trademarks NETGEAR and the NETGEAR logo are registered trademarks and ProSecure is a trademark of NETGEAR, Inc. Microsoft, Windows, and Windows NT are registered trademarks of Microsoft Corporation. Other brand and product names are registered trademarks or trademarks of...»

«Literature Reviews 1. What is a Literature Review?2. Choosing Material 3. Searching for Good Material 4. Assessing the Literature 5. Developing the Literature Review 6. Placing the Literature Review in the Dissertation/Thesis 7. Structuring the Literature Review 8. Writing Up the Literature Review 1. What is a Literature Review? A literature review is simply a summary of what existing scholarship knows about a particular topic. It is always based on secondary sources – that is, what other...»

«AC Current Data Logger AC Current Data Logger OM-DLAC DATA LOGGER INSTRUCTIONS The OMEGA OM-DLAC Data Logger is a self-contained precision instrument for recording AC Current using a clamp on probe. The OM-DLAC can store up to 16,000 measurements for each recording. The recordings can be read using the supplied PC interface or the optional OM-DP3 Data Plotter. The Windows™ compatible software allows the user to set the OM-DLAC for a recording session, read the recorded data in text or...»

«Witness: Characters Around the Cross Wishy-Washy Character: Pilate—crucifying Jesus by non-commitment Matthew 27:19-24 Pastor Brian Messler March 23, 2014 Prayer: For the time we have here this morning, together as the body of Christ, we thank you, God. For the moments where your Spirit hovers over our lives and fills us with hope, we thank you. We pray that our time together, honoring and praising you, will bring you all the glory. May we learn from the people who interacted with Jesus as he...»


«Sharing Responsibility for Libraries: “More than a Library” Stony Stratford Library www.milton-keynes.gov.uk/libraries June 2015 Page 2 of 15 Sharing Responsibility for Libraries Programme: More than a Library! Contents Location Layout Introduction Sharing Responsibilities: The Context The Council’s “Eight Point Core Library Offer” Performance and Use Developing Options Together Performance and Use Knowledge about Customers Library Stock and Book Issues Self Service Plans Staffing...»

«FILED United States Court of Appeals Tenth Circuit August 4, 2015 PUBLISH Elisabeth A. Shumaker Clerk of Court UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS TENTH CIRCUIT KEITH CRESSMAN, Plaintiff Appellant, v. No. 14-6020 MICHAEL C. THOMPSON, in his official capacity as Secretary of Safety and Security and as the Commissioner of Public Safety for the State of Oklahoma; PAULA ALLEN, individually and in her official capacity as Licensing Services Hearing Officer for the Oklahoma Department of Public Safety;...»

«LDSS-4148C (Rev. 07/16) Book 3 What You Should Know If You Have an Emergency Questions and Answers LDSS-4148C (Rev. 07/16) If you are blind or seriously visually impaired and need an application or these instructions in an alternative format, you may request them from your social services district. The following alternative formats are available: • Large print;• Data format (a screen-reader accessible electronic file);• Audio format (an audio transcription of the instructions or...»

«WHY WAS THERE A LANGUAGE CONTROVERSY IN GREECE? Peter Mackridge Lecture at the British School at Athens, 14 September 2009 to launch his book Language and National Identity in Greece, 1766-1976 (Oxford 2009) I’ll try to give an immediate but perhaps crude answer to the question posed in my title. The two chief factors were (a) conflicting views about Greek society, culture and education, and (b) conflicting beliefs about the relationship between the modern Greeks and the ancient Greeks....»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.thesis.xlibx.info - Thesis, documentation, books

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.