FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Thesis, documentation, books

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |

«Bashing the Migrant Climbers: Interethnic Classification Struggles in German City Neighborhoods FERDINAND SUTTERLÜTY and SIGHARD NECKEL Abstract ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Volume 30.4 December 2006 798–815 International Journal of Urban and Regional Research


Bashing the Migrant Climbers:

Interethnic Classification Struggles

in German City Neighborhoods



This article examines the symbolic order of the relationships between various social

groups in disadvantaged neighborhoods and shows that ethnicity is the main reference point of derogatory designations or ‘negative classifications’. Using two districts in German cities as examples, the semantic patterns of mutual negative classifications among autochthonous individuals and their Turkish neighbors are reconstructed. Upwardly mobile individuals of Turkish origin are the most frequent targets of stigmatization. This fact is explained by the existence of a deep symbolic dimension of social inequality that conceives of ethnicity in terms of kinship relations. The socially inclusive or exclusive effects of negative interethnic classifications and the related classification struggles depend on three factors: the internal, i.e. gradual or categorical logic of the classification patterns;

the form and process of conflict resolution; and the social contexts in which negative classifications are used. While the disintegrating effects of negative classifications are curbed by institutionalized norms in local politics and economic life, there only exist informal performative norms of interaction in the life-world, and here these classifications can more easily lead to social exclusion and ethnic separation.

The social structure of modern societies represents an order of objective inequalities among social classes, professions, ethnic groups and the sexes. Differences in social structure always give rise to interpretations and evaluations that not only shape the social exchanges among various groups, even in their most minor everyday life interactions, but that also determine the ‘daily class struggle’ (Bourdieu, 1990 [1987]: 134). Social structure can thus be said to form a symbolic order that is based on mutual classifications among different social groups — that is, on categorizing labels and evaluations.

Symbolic orders that are produced in the daily interaction among different social groups grant recognition and show disrespect in various ways. The corresponding classifications influence the groups’ opportunities to acquire material and cultural assets and have a direct impact not only on the objective structure of social inequalities, but also on the respective groups’ potential to integrate. ‘Negative’ (meaning pejorative or discriminatory) classifications are especially relevant to integration, since classifications can exclude certain social groups from participating in society.

In an ethnographic research project conducted in two disadvantaged urban neighborhoods between 2002 and 2005,1 we studied the exclusionary and, at times, integrative effects of negative classifications. However, before we present the main goals Translated from the German by Adam Blauhut.

1 The project was entitled ‘Negative Klassifikationen: Ideologien der Ungleichwertigkeit in den symbolischen Ordnungen gegenwärtiger Sozialgruppen’ [Negative Classifications: Ideologies of © 2006 The Authors. Journal Compilation © 2006 Joint Editors and Blackwell Publishing Ltd. Published by Blackwell Publishing. 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK and 350 Main St, Malden, MA 02148, USA Interethnic classification struggles in German city neighborhoods 799 and central results of this research project, we would like to systematically examine the concepts of social classification and of classification struggles.

Social classifications Social classifications and their positive or negative evaluations are universal human phenomena. As scholars from different disciplines have shown, they structure the social environment and provide a foundation for guiding the actions of people and groups.

Furthermore, classifications are orientation systems that allow individuals and groups to define their place in society (see, in particular, Douglas, 1973; Tajfel, 1981; Bowker and Star, 2002). In sociology, the concept of classification is inextricably linked to the name Durkheim and his thesis of a ‘social constitution of the categories’ (Durkheim and Mauss, 1963 [1903]; Durkheim, 1976 [1912]). Taking ‘primitive classification’ in totemic societies as an example, Durkheim endeavored to show that such fundamental concepts as space and time, force and causality, as well as the rules of logical association reflect the inner structure and operation of their respective societies and are even causally determined by them. Durkheim derives entire cosmologies from social order — that is, from the morphological and organizational properties of the societies he studied.

According to Durkheim, the complex division of these societies into tribes, phratries and clans on the one hand, and marriage classes on the other, determines the categories to which natural phenomena are assigned as well as their relations to one another (as is well known, the key mechanism linking nature and society is the system of totems, which assigns particular trees, animals and celestial bodies to the tribes, phratries, clans and marriage classes).

Durkheim’s great accomplishment was to identify classification as an important aspect of culture and to incorporate it as a theoretical concept into sociological analysis. Durkheim also emphasized the collective nature of the categories that form the basis of social and cosmic orders and that control the perceptions of social groups.

In doing so, Durkheim demonstrated that social categorizations are ‘collective representations’ (Durkheim, 1976 [1912]: 435) — ideas that do not emerge from the mental states of the individual but which lie deep within social structures and precede individual thought. This implies that classification systems are as variegated as all historical forms of society and that they vary according to historical, social and cultural contexts. In this sense, each and every society is ‘an individuality itself, which has its own personal physiognomy and its idiosyncrasies’ (ibid.: 444).

That being said, the specific formulation and derivation of these fundamental insights in Durkheim’s work have been criticized by many. In addition to raising serious empirical, logical and methodological objections to the notion of a direct parallelism between social structures and classification systems, scholars have rejected Durkheim’s basic evolutionary assumption that all later classification systems have their original form in totemic society. Further, the causal interpretation of the connection between the organization of society and the ideas prevalent in it has proved untenable (Lukes, 1985: 435). Nonetheless, it can be a very productive undertaking to study the connection Durkheim postulated between symbolic classification and social structure (cf. Needham, 1969: xxxvi; Allen, 1994: 62). With an eye toward the classifications that predominate in current symbolic orders of social inequality, one must emphasize that Durkheim’s theory is tailored primarily to structural aspects: to the inner structure of classification and knowledge systems and to their relationship with the properties of social structures.

Inequality in the Symbolic Orders of Current Social Groups]. It was affiliated with both the Institut für Sozialforschung in Frankfurt am Main and the research association ‘Desintegrationsprozesse — Stärkung von Integrationspotentialen einer modernen Gesellschaft’, which was funded by the Federal Ministry of Education and Research. The research team included Ina Walter in addition to the two authors.

–  –  –

Classification struggles The strengths of Durkheim’s structural theory result in grave flaws from the perspective of a theory of action. Durkheim lacks a set of conceptual instruments to accommodate a basic feature of social classifications, namely, the fact that they are generated and perpetuated by concrete practices of social action. Worsley (1956) rightly criticizes the mechanical view of societies and collective knowledge structures in Durkheim’s late work on the sociology of religion (1976 [1912]), in which, as Worsley points out, social action plays a negligible role. This criticism, which excludes Durkheim’s description of collective rituals (Joas, 1987: 282), is particularly applicable to the essay on classification that Durkheim co-authored with Mauss (Durkheim and Mauss, 1963 [1903]). Naturally, classification patterns are not generated anew with each single action but already form its basis. They guide it as long as they do not become problematic themselves. But this does not change the fact that classification systems are crystallizations of past classification acts.

In response to Durkheim’s extensive blindness to action theory, one must first object that classifications, rather than being mere static phenomena, are an objectification of a process known as ‘classifying’ (cf. Ellen, 1979: 27). Further, it must be pointed out that within individual societies there exists a variety of classification systems that may come into conflict with each other. One reason Durkheim overlooked this point is that his studies focused principally on the social makeup of the categories used by societies to

grasp their natural environment. Here one encounters a one-sided classification process:

plants, animals and stars are not able to protest against their assignment to the order of things or engage in the act of categorizing themselves. By contrast, classifications of the social environment are embedded in a two-way process (Starr, 1992: 157). They touch upon the identities of individuals and groups, who can in turn confront the classifiers with their self-image and challenge the legitimacy of the ‘foreign’ image being imposed on them. As Starr (ibid.) emphasizes, this is particularly true of modern democratic societies.

By focusing on a structural homology between society and categorical world disclosure (Welterschließung), Durkheim also loses sight of the content of the social classifications that he uses as models for cosmologies and basic categories of human thought. When separated from content, however, the ‘social’ aspect of classification systems is ‘a label on an empty jar’ (Worsley, 1956: 53). The cognitive identification of groups, to which positive or negative evaluations subsequently become attached, is itself a classification that is often fought over. But Durkheim attaches as little importance to this as to the diverse meanings that individual classifications can take on in social use. Their use not only performs a denotative descriptive function, but is also characterized by manifold connotations and by various links to different semantic fields. For instance, the person who calls welfare recipients ‘social parasites’ not only places them in the category of individuals who make illegitimate demands on the welfare state. He also triggers associations with the disagreeable parasites from the animal kingdom and methods of dealing with them. These different levels of meaning typically manifest themselves in symbolic struggles between different social groups.

It was above all Bourdieu (1984 [1979]; 1990 [1987]) who shed light on the evaluative, relational and conflictual properties of social classifications. These properties are extremely important in modern societies since they do not, at least in principle, grant social recognition or show contempt according to the asymmetrical patterns of inherited group privilege. In such societies, hierarchies of economic and cultural capital that are based on the availability of both material resources and utilizable knowledge are not entirely self-perpetuating. Rather, the value of status positions must be constantly renegotiated. This is the source of evaluative social struggles in which the symbolic capital of social recognition is the prize. The resulting ‘hierarchy of values granted to individuals and groups’ (Bourdieu, 1990 [1987]: 135) creates the symbolic order of a International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 30.4 © 2006 The Authors. Journal Compilation © 2006 Joint Editors and Blackwell Publishing Ltd.

Interethnic classification struggles in German city neighborhoods 801 society which is organized along the lines of ‘the logic of difference, of a differential variation’ (ibid.: 133; see also Neckel, 1991: 231).

Against this backdrop, Bourdieu regards classification conflicts as ‘symbolic struggles for the power to produce and to impose a vision of the legitimate world’ (1990 [1987]: 134; cf. Bourdieu, 1984 [1979]: 479). What distinguishes symbolic power from the other forms of power that are based on physical, economic and social capital is the fact that the enforcement of a world-view depends on recognition by others (Bourdieu, 1998 [1994]: 47). Bourdieu largely views recognition of a world-view and the corresponding social demarcations as tacit approval of the conditions of an established order — an order that seeks to camouflage its arbitrary foundations in the aura of the natural. However, Bourdieu’s concept of symbolic power only assumes a specific meaning when he sufficiently emphasizes the dependence of symbolic power on recognition by others and thereby gives reasons for the relative autonomy of symbolic capital in relation to other forms (cf. Schwingel, 1993: 103).

In consequence, the symbolic sphere is never secure and particularly prone to struggles among social groups. According to Bourdieu, the ‘classificatory systems’ that groups struggle to enforce or overturn on a daily basis are ‘overtly or covertly aimed at satisfying the interests of a group’ (1984 [1979]: 477). Even if opposing formulations can be found in Bourdieu’s work, this theory would suggest that the criteria of utility can be understood as being ultimately definitive for ‘collective representations’. In symbolic struggles, however, normative reasons for action can also be relevant because they articulate the moral concepts, lifestyles and collective identities of social groups.

Pages:   || 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |

Similar works:

«A model for successful student teams Vreda PIETERSE1 and Lisa THOMPSON2 University of Pretoria, Department of Computer Science, Lynnwood Road, Pretoria Tel: +27 12 4203652, Fax: +27 12 3625188, Email: vreda.pieterse@up.ac.za University of Pretoria, Department of Information Science, Lynnwood Road, Pretoria Tel: +27 12 430, Fax: +27 12, Email: lisa.thompson@up.ac.za Abstract We are of opinion that students learn more about teams from positive team experiences than they do from negative ones,...»

«Home Search Collections Journals About Contact us My IOPscience AsyncStageOut: Distributed user data management for CMS Analysis This content has been downloaded from IOPscience. Please scroll down to see the full text. 2015 J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 664 062052 (http://iopscience.iop.org/1742-6596/664/6/062052) View the table of contents for this issue, or go to the journal homepage for more Download details: IP Address: This content was downloaded on 08/01/2016 at 20:18 Please note...»

«Svarte sekunder (Inspector Konrad Sejer #6) Karin Fossum Helga Svarte sekunder (Inspector Konrad Sejer #6) Joner opplever alle foreldres mareritt. Datteren, Ida, snart ti år, skal naked en tur i kiosken for å kjøpe siste nummer av hestebladet, Wendy og Bugg for resten av pengene. Samme ettermiddag er Ida sporløst borte.Jacob Skarre noterte på en blokk etter hvert som kvinnen snakket, og flere motstridende følelser vokste fram i ham. Ida Joner, en ti år gammel jente fra Glassverket, var...»

«INTERNATIONAL BLACK SEA UNIVERSITY FACULTY OF EDUCATION AND HUMANITIES Enhancing Learner-Centered English as a Foreign Language (EFL) Learning (Reading Comprehension Skills) through Mobile Media Tahsin YAĞCI Extended Abstract of Doctoral Dissertation in Education Sciences Tbilisi, 2016 Scientific Supervisor: Ekaterine Pipia Professor, Doctor at International Black Sea University Experts Assoc. Prof. Dr. Nikoloz Parjanadze. Assoc. Prof. Dr. Nino Tvalchrelidze. Opponents Assoc. Prof. Dr. Tamar...»

«Hunehune Kalo Weekly Newsletter Volume 14 Issue 9 Ka Lä 3 o ÿOkakopa 2013 Kanu o ka ‘Äina New Century Public Charter School Mana‘o Nui Aloha mai käkou This week marks the end of the first quarter of school. It seems like just yesterday that we were welcoming all the haumäna back to school. The end of the quarter is an excellent time to carefully review past performance and conduct and to set new goals to assure continuous growth throughout the year. It is also an opportunity to prepare...»

«COTTON PHYSIOLOGY NUMBER ONE THE COTTON FOUNDATION REFERENCE BOOK SERIES Edited by Jack R. Mauney and James McD. Stewart COTTON PHYSIOLOGY THE COTTON FOUNDATION Reference Book Series The Cotton Foundation was created in 1955 to foster innovative research and education not covered by other private or public agencies. It is supported by many of America's finest agri-industries and financial institutions, including banks, cotton magazines, and manufacturers of machinery, chemicals and other inputs...»

«Job Control Language About the Tutorial Job Control Language (JCL) is the command language of Multiple Virtual Storage (MVS), which is the commonly used Operating System in the IBM Mainframe computers. JCL identifies the program to be executed, the inputs that are required and the location of the input/output, and informs the Operating System through Job control Statements. In mainframe environment, programs can be executed in batch and online modes. JCL is used for submitting a program for...»

«E1409 V1 REV Public Disclosure Authorized Annex 8. Environmental Guidelines KYRGYZ REPUBLIC Community Development and Investment Agency Agentstvo Razvitiya i Investirovaniya Soobschestv (ARIS) Public Disclosure Authorized Second Village Investment Project Updated Public Disclosure Authorized GUIDELINES for Environmental Review of Micro-projects Public Disclosure Authorized 1 May 2006 CONTENTS 1. Purpose and Content 2. National Regulations 3. World Bank Safeguard Policies 4. Micro-project...»

«VTT PUBLICATIONS 737 Virpi Oksman The mobile phone: A medium in itself PUBLICATIONS 737 The mobile phone: A medium in itself Virpi Oksman Academic dissertation to be presented with the permission of the Faculty of Social Sciences of the University of Tampere, for public discussion in the Auditorium Pinni B 1097, Kanslerinrinne 1, Tampere, on May 28th, 2010, at 12 o’clock. ISBN 978-951-38-7394-3 (soft back ed.) ISSN 1235-0621 (soft back ed.) ISBN 978-951-38-7395-0 (URL:...»

«United States Department of Labor Employees’ Compensation Appeals Board ) M.W., Appellant ) ) and ) Docket No. 11-1850 ) Issued: March 21, 2012 DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, SOUTHWEST ) POWER ADMINISTRATION, Tulsa, OK, ) Employer ) ) Appearances: Case Submitted on the Record Alan J. Shapiro, Esq., for the appellant Office of Solicitor, for the Director DECISION AND ORDER Before: RICHARD J. DASCHBACH, Chief Judge COLLEEN DUFFY KIKO, Judge JAMES A. HAYNES, Alternate Judge JURISDICTION On August 9,...»

«PUBLISHED UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT  UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Plaintiff-Appellee, v.  HUMBERTO JOSE CASTILLO-PENA, No. 10-5080 a/k/a Umberto Jose Castillo, a/k/a Erick Rene Cardona-Lajara, a/k/a Ronald Delarocha, a/k/a Oscar Monriel, a/k/a Jimmy Lajara,  Defendant-Appellant. Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, at Alexandria. Gerald Bruce Lee, District Judge. (1:10-cr-00100-GBL-1) Argued: January 24, 2012...»

«Building bridges, breaking barriers The smart approach to distance between disciplines in research projects FINAL REPORT A study prepared for the European Commission Digital Agenda for Europe This study was carried out for the European Commission by Authors: Jamal Shahin Trisha Meyer Dariusz Kloza Katja Biedenkopf Source cover image: Freeimages, 2014. Colorful Background III. Retrieved on October 14, 2014 from http://www.freeimages.com/photo/1041989 Internal identification Contract number:...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.thesis.xlibx.info - Thesis, documentation, books

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.